Source Lists:

Wednesday, August 11, 2021

#3 The Godfather (1972)

I have always loved this movie, and Godfather II even more. Watching it again these days though, all I could think about was the turbulent moment we are living through. As Robert Ebert notes in this review, this movie is so absorbing that we actually romanticized organized crime in the US. 

Ebert: “During the movie we see not a single actual civilian victim of organized crime. No women trapped into prostitution. No lives wrecked by gambling. No victims of theft, fraud or protection rackets. The only police officer with a significant speaking role is corrupt.” 

Organized crime affects every single one of us in the form of higher taxes and fewer social services as our law enforcement agencies work to combat the violence, financial crimes, cybercrimes, and corruption. And it’s global now. Our national security apparatus has long deemed Transnational Organized Crime as a national security threat and a threat to democracy around the world. All those crimes make everything more expensive for the rest of us. It endangers our health through human trafficking and counterfeit pharmaceuticals. And it corrupts local, state, and national officials, who are supposed to be working for us. 

This time around, watching The Godfather got me thinking about other forms of organized crime in our history. More specifically, other times when too much power was held by too few, leading to an oligarchy of crime and corruption. I believe that this is precisely what is causing our current misery and tumult, so I wanted to look for examples of where it has happened before. 



Southern Planters & Slavery

I’ve been reading a historical fiction series about the Civil War and it’s hard not to see the southern planter class through an “organized crime” lens. If oligarchy is defined as a power structure that allows a few individuals to rule in a way that benefits them to the exclusion of the rest of society, it is clear they were an oligarchy. It was an aristocracy built on slave labor and it gave them political clout that allowed them to expand their slaveholding land into Native American territories so they could cling to power as each new state was added to the Union. 

If you are thinking it is too extreme to refer to southern planter/slaveholders as “organized crime”, let’s consider their behavior immediately before and after they lost the Civil War.

When Lincoln was elected, southern Democrats - the pro-slavery party - held almost half the seats in the Senate and had additional northern allies that they could control.  Lincoln would have been virtually powerless on the issue of slavery, not to mention he repeatedly said he didn’t intend to focus on it. The Democrats had a majority of the Supreme Court. They had just had a decade of significant legislation and Supreme Court rulings in favor of slavery. Throughout this period, by the way, they demanded the federal government’s help in enforcing fugitive slave control OVER northern states’ rights. 

They left the Union because they disagreed with northerners. Mississippi complained that northerners believed in “negro equality” and this was enough to justify secession. Texas also said they had to leave because northerners were “proclaiming the debasing doctrine of equality of all men, irrespective of race or color”. Secession was illegal and shameful because they only did it to save their oligarchy.

Immediately after losing the war, the south began to institute black codes across the south. The point of these laws were to restrict the freedom of the former slaves and make sure they were still available to work on the plantations. These laws prohibited Black people from holding any occupation other than farmer or servant unless they paid an annual tax. They punished anyone who offered higher wages to a Black laborer who was already employed. 

But wait there's more! Former confederate veterans formed a terrorist organization whose entire purpose was to punish Black and white Republicans with harassment, torture, and murder. The original leadership of the Ku Klux Klan included lawyers, physicians, police officers, and plantation owners.

Members of the planter class didn’t start out as gangsters like the Corleones. But when the oligarchy is threatened, they immediately morph into a criminal enterprise. They break laws and harm people to keep it.

Organized crime is described as a “continuing criminal enterprise that rationally works to profit from illicit activities that are often in great public demand. Its continuing existence is maintained through corruption of public officials and the use of intimidation, threats or force to protect its operations.” Ding, ding, ding.



California Growers & Fair Wages

Next, I dug into the dust bowl years a little bit and the fight for fair wages. It should come as no surprise to you that this was also inspired by a novel that my book club selected earlier this year. 

The dust bowl was the biggest migration of Americans in history. Many headed to California, which quickly became overrun with migrants. Most of the farms in California were corporate-owned and they used this to their advantage - repeatedly lowering wages and pocketing the profits, while using their wealth and political power to convince law enforcement and locals that the migrants were subhuman and deserved no help.  The larger farms had onsite lodging and company stores for the laborers. These company stores charged high prices for goods and allowed migrants to incur debt that could only be paid off with wages, keeping them tied to their situation and ensuring they had no agency.

Again, it seems like a stretch to call this completely legal display of free market capitalism “organized crime”. But look at their actions when the subjugated people push back via a strike. 

First, they actively prevented workers from assembling to try to improve their lot. They encouraged police to raid gatherings and beat up anyone who either tried to educate pickers or tried to learn as a picker. Second, they used their wealth and power to control the public opinion, actively ensuring other community members ostracized the migrants from all of the rest of society, including little kids attending school or getting medical care. And finally, of course, they led or encouraged vigilante mobs who beat and murdered them for striking. 

Again, these growers were not initially behaving like a crime syndicate. They were not all bad people any more than any group of humans has “bad” or “good” people in it. But once they had so much power in so few hands, it didn't seem to matter that they were raking in record profits, they were ready to destroy everything to keep the status quo. It’s like something switches in peoples’ brains in these situations and they lose their sense of right and wrong. What was that definition of organized crime again? Oh yeah, “its continuing existence is maintained through corruption of public officials and the use of intimidation, threats or force to protect its operations.” See what I mean?


Today

I have been studying how Transnational Organized Crime is affecting us right now, particularly where it has already infiltrated our government, media, and other institutions. We know, through court transcripts and indictments, that foreign groups have been actively working to divide Americans by spreading disinformation, fear, and hate for years. We also know that citizens are repeatedly banned from various social media sites for spreading disinformation. And yet.

Today, citizens are showing up at local school board and town council meetings and spewing conspiracy theories, punching each other, and harassing teachers and other officials. People are pretending that COVID precautions and the vaccine are nefarious when they absolutely are not and never have been. There’s an actual cult that has sprouted up and is being actively nurtured, with believers around the world. Members of this QAnon cult have committed crimes, deserted their children, and isolated themselves from the people they love rather than give up the ludicrous farce that the world has been taken over by a secret group of people who eat and molest children. Most alarming to me, well-known public figures are advocating for fascist dictators over our own country!

Why? Who benefits when Americans are exhausted, afraid, sick, and ready to surrender our Republic? This is much bigger than left/right politics. It is absolutely some form of organized crime like the examples I shared above. Some group of oligarchs - whether foreign, like the well-known Russian mafia, or domestic, like the Koch enterprise/Federalist Society - is threatened and they are acting exactly as the groups above acted. Or, God help us, perhaps they have joined forces. I want to know who they are. I want all of their damn names and I want them tried and sent to prison.

If this topic interests you, I encourage you to give the podcast The World Beneath a listen. It’s a rich and groundbreaking series that examines how the underworld’s criminal figures have morphed and changed as organized crime went global. 

I also suggest you follow the Pegasus Project, which is an international investigative journalism initiative that revealed that governments all over the world have been using spyware developed by an Israeli tech firm to monitor people. If you enjoy spy thrillers, we’ve got one right here in real life. This software can access victims' data, messages, and photos, and can turn on the phone’s microphone, camera, and geolocation. Absolutely terrifying. A global weapon to silence truth. I expect we will learn more about the perpetrators in the future.

Times are dire, I know. But we’ve gotten out of scary moments before, and we will again, as long as most of us know how important the moment is. Pay attention, but not so much that you get discouraged and lose hope. Take care of yourself. 

Be wary of those who constantly tell you that your fellow Americans are to blame. Blame elected officials? Absolutely. They literally have staff to ensure their information is as accurate as possible. Average Americans do not. 

I know, I’m angry with the anti-vax crowd too, but it helps me to remember they are victims of our very first global disinformation war of the social media era and, as a country, we aren’t doing enough to fight it because it’s such a new phenomenon. They are drowning in it and it’s killing them and us. 

I know, I also think they should be smart enough to understand the difference between con artists and grifters, and professional journalists and epidemiologists. Just remember there are forces actively trying to keep them confused, scared, angry, and uninformed. Actively trying to hurt them. 

Talk about it with your friends and family and make sure people understand how serious this moment is.

Most of all, remember how important your actions are. Remember how vital your individual acts of kindness are to the greater world. Be kind and be a good example. Remember that most people are actually good - the bad ones just get the headlines. We are going to need each other to make it through this moment and there are more of us than we think.




Sunday, July 18, 2021

#5 The Beatles, Abbey Road (1969)

Have you ever thought about the word “time”? I don’t mean the time of day, I mean the way we use the word to describe an era, a generation, a time in history. What about “all time”? The eternity of humans on earth.

I picture a river. I’m barefoot, on the bank of a mature and substantial river running from my left to my right. It’s mostly calm, greenish blue water with some faster moving spots too. And it makes that wonderful sound that rivers make. It burbles and splashes and ripples - sounds of currents I can’t see. It goes around lazy bends from time to time but it stretches as far as I can see in either direction. I walk in at the shallow river’s edge and it feels perfect. Refreshing but not cold. Warm enough, but not tepid.

Now imagine that the river represents all of humanity. To our left, all of our past. Every human who ever lived on the earth. All of the honorable and divine moments of human kindness, generosity, ingenuity, love. All of those humans whose names we will never know and who will not be remembered. Every single human who chose good over evil has shaped our world into what it is today and has helped get us here. Each one is admirable and I’m so grateful to them for the gift of this moment. Our moment.  

Deep below the surface of our river is the muck of nastiness. Humans who choose to kill or harm or steal. Or profit from the suffering of others. Humans who choose fear and hate. Humans who lie or who are unkind. We all know what we are capable of when we are at our worst. Our river is so strong that it can handle this relatively small bit of muck. Too much muck and it will threaten the health of the river and we will need a massive cleanup project to avoid losing it entirely, so we all keep a close eye on it. We understand that we don’t own it; rather, we are temporary custodians and we need to ensure that it is healthy and strong for those who come after us.

Where I stand in our river, my feet are in the muck. They aren’t submerged, and I am free to move around, but I can feel it. I feel the revulsion as its cold clamminess squishes between my toes. But I stand atop it, knowing the worst. I learn from their mistakes and I choose kindness.

Now let’s look to our right. Future generations of humanity spread out as far as we can see on our same winding waterway. Immediate futures that we can make educated guesses about. Distant futures that we cannot even imagine and that creative artists often frame for our consideration and enjoyment. What will they make of us? What art and news and policy will they look back at hundreds or thousands of years from now and admire? Or be embarrassed by? Are we doing everything we can to ensure our river is still as clean and beautiful for them as we can make it? Every act in our daily lives, no matter how small, affects the river. Every single one of us changes our current and future worlds with our every action. We are, for them, history. Let’s make sure we treasure the dignity and gravity with which we have been entrusted.

As I gaze in wonderment, I can feel that this sublime and majestic river is, by its nature, good. When we don’t choose kindness, every single one of us has to go out of our way to override that inner voice we all have - our conscience reminds us that we know right from wrong. Our default setting is goodness and it’s indisputable. Living our lives can be so hard and I find this fact so reassuring, overwhelming even. Especially during those times when I am filled with doubt or worry. And we cannot ignore the muck between our toes. It exists and we succumb to it from time to time. But we are wired for good. 

The major world religions use a lot of water-related imagery. Christians and Muslims believe God created man and all other creatures out of water. Both religions believe water symbolizes purity, like in baptism rituals. Muslims believe water is the source of life and a symbol of paradise. Hindus believe water holds purifying and cleansing powers. They value cleanliness of body and soul so they use water in many of their rituals as well.

I think about the river all the time. Sometimes I think it is God. After all, if you believe in God, you certainly know it’s not a white-haired dude hanging out ELSEWHERE. It’s right here, with us, in us, all the time. I never know exactly what I believe about God. But if you look at all of the wondrous things we humans are capable of, the astounding power that human love has to create and transform lives all along this eternal river… to me, that is God. Or our “source”, or the universe, or whatever you feel comfortable calling it. The Divine. Accessible to us at all times. Just dip your toe in. 

Consider truly gifted artists such as The Beatles or Bob Dylan or F. Scott Fitzgerald. Something in their art spoke to so many of us that we lifted them up en masse so we could spread their message and so we could speak to each other about their work. They tapped deeply into our river - our shared humanity that tethers us together. They practiced and honed their craft and found a way to see into our souls and reflect our *selves* back to us. They speak to what our moment in the river FEELS like. We, the humans of this place and time, broadly agree that these are the messages we want to send to our future. To our beloved future humans, this is what it was like for us during our moment on this earth. These messages represent our fears and joys and trials and observations. Our calls for improvement and progress. Our heartbreak when we suffer. This is us. Isn’t that just so freaking cool?

Anyway, Abbey Road is great. Apparently I saw God or something so, you know, you should listen to it.



Thursday, July 8, 2021

#2 The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald

Number two on the list of the best novels of all time is The Great Gatsby. Like many of us, I read this years ago in high school or college. I remember it as a story about love, a tragedy of a lost love. Goodness no. This time around, I was struck by everything in this novel being the opposite of love.

What is the opposite of love? The thesaurus says the answer is hate. Then there’s the famous quote, “the opposite of love is not hate, it’s indifference”, which we can easily identify with.  The truth is that the opposite of love is actually fear.

Fear of failure. Fear of what people will think of me. Fear that I will look stupid. Fear of the unknown. Fear of revealing myself, of exposing my true self. Fear of rejection. Fear that I am not worthy. Every human on the planet feels these fears from time to time. But when fear kicks into overdrive, it blocks you from all kinds of love.


Let’s take a look at some of the characters.

Nick Carraway: Nick, our earnest narrator, is afraid of being too judgmental and prides himself on being tolerant, honest, and objective. Nick is not at all honest in the book. Afraid of being an outcast, Nick gets sucked into Gatsby’s world, accepts drinks when he doesn’t feel like it, hangs out with people he doesn’t like, dates a woman with opposite values, and hides truths from everyone. Nick’s fears lead him to leave the east coast for the Midwest at the end of the novel. I understand that Fitzgerald’s goal is for us to see the east coast as “American excess” and the Midwest as “getting back to our morals and values”, but we all know our poor choices and our struggles are not reliant on our zip code.

“I was within and without, simultaneously enchanted and repelled by the inexhaustible variety of life.”

Daisy Buchanan: We are meant to perceive Daisy as having charm, wealth, and sophistication. As you can imagine, these are all the things a poverty-stricken Gatsby could want from life. However, Daisy is by far the weakest and most pathetic character in the novel. It is not clear whether she is capable of loving Gatsby, her husband, or her child. She told Gatsby she would wait for him until after the war, then married Tom instead. She had an affair with Gatsby while married to Tom. She drove drunk, killed a woman, and let Gatsby take the blame. She used her money to run and hide afterwards. Daisy’s crippling fear is caring for others in any way that will hold her accountable.

“If personality is an unbroken series of successful gestures, then there was something gorgeous about him.”

Tom Buchanan: Tom is afraid of Gatsby’s “new wealth” because it is a threat to his worldview. His worldview is that people with money have it because they deserve it and should be permanent members of an American aristocracy. (Fuck off, Tom.)

“You see I usually find myself among strangers because I drift here and there trying to forget the sad things that happened to me.”

Jay Gatsby: Gatsby’s biggest fear is being trapped in the poverty and tedious insignificance of his youth.  When he first meets Daisy, he hides his past from her because he’s afraid she won’t love him if she knows the truth. He’s so desperate to avoid destitution that he chooses a life of crime to win the love of someone who never even truly knew him; indeed, Gatsby never truly sees Daisy for who she is either. Daisy does nothing to deserve anyone’s love and admiration. His fear prevents him from seeing her fully. Gatsby may have loved Daisy at some point, but by the time of the novel's setting, she has become just another thing he needs to acquire to fulfill the image of his reinvented, illusory self.

“It was one of those rare smiles with a quality of eternal reassurance in it, that you may come across four or five times in life. It faced, or seemed to face, the whole external world for an instant and then concentrated on you with an irresistible prejudice in your favor. It understood you just as far as you wanted to be understood, believed in you as you would like to believe in yourself.”


Because of all the fear, there is no love anywhere. I think this is what makes this book such a classic, what makes it speak to us time and again. It is a dystopian tale so terrible, so bereft of any meaningful, honorable lives, that we can’t look away. We want to learn from this, we want to do everything in our power not to live these lives, not to make these terrible choices. And all the while, this grim dystopia is laid out for us in the most beautiful prose ever written, perfectly capturing so many of the other human emotions we all experience. The incongruity is too exquisite, too satisfying to abandon. Fitzgerald sees us. I believe he wants us to be afraid of becoming these characters. Make good choices. Love with all your might.

“The bar is in full swing, and floating rounds of cocktails permeate the garden outside, until the air is alive with chatter and laughter, and casual innuendo and introductions forgotten on the spot, and enthusiastic meetings between women who never knew each other’s names.

The lights grow brighter as the earth lurches away from the sun, and now the orchestra is playing yellow cocktail music, and the opera of voices pitches a key higher. Laughter is easier minute by minute, spilled with prodigality, tipped out at a cheerful word.”